Understanding and Managing Sudden Oak Death in California

3.4. Assessing Fire Hazard Related to SOD-Killed Trees

The types of fuels formed from SOD-killed trees are related to how fast the tree has died, whether failures occurred before or after tree death, and the length of time since tree death (see also figure 2-2A and figure 2-2B, and 2.2.3.2. SOD-related mortality and fire). Table 3-5 shows examples of dead fuels that may accumulate in coast live oak stands affected by SOD. The left two columns show aerial fuels associated with standing SOD-killed trees. The right two columns demonstrate how fuels degrade over time when they are on the ground. Stages of degradation for trees that are dead and defoliated before failure are about 1 to 2 years advanced compared with green failures, but are similar if the date of tree death is used as the starting time reference point. Icons to the left of each photo illustrating tree condition are the same as used in figure 2-2.

Note that all standing dead trees have an elevated risk of failure and in particular, can pose a hazard to firefighting personnel.

Table 3-5—Definitions of aerial fuels that develop over time in standing dead coast live oaks killed by SOD

Factor

Level

icon

Photo

Fuel stage

Dead1. Standing dead with leaves

dead standing icon dead w leaves

Time period

1-2 years after tree death

Primary fuel type(s)

Aerial

Fire effects

Canopy readily ignited, will serve as source of embers

Fuel stage

Dead2. Standing dead without leaves, with fine branches

dead and defoliated

Time period

2-3+ years after tree death

Primary fuel type(s)

Aerial

Fire effects

Canopy may ignite if sufficiently low and dense. Failure risk is high.

Fuel stage

Dead3. Standing dead with branch failures, some fine branches present

dead standing fialed br icon

Time period

2-4+ years after tree death

Primary fuel type(s)

Surface, aerial

Fire effects

Piles of failed branches (fuel stage B2 to B3) increase depth of ground fuel layer, can form fuel ladders to connect ground and aerial fuels. Aerial fuels may be too sparse to ignite readily but are highly prone to failure.

Fuel stage

Dead4. Snag, large diameter stems failed

snag icon standing snag

Time period

4-6+ years after tree death

Primary fuel type(s)

Surface

Fire effects

Large standing stems do not easily ignite, but are prone to fail. Debris piles are fuel stage B3 to B4, dominated by large diameter branches that may be mostly decayed. Fine fuels are decayed and in or near duff layer

 

 

Table 3-6—Definitions of ground fuels that develop over time in failed coast live oaks killed by SOD

Factor

Level

 

Photo and icon

Fuel stage

Failed1. Failed tree or branch with leaves

failed w leaves icon

Failed 1

Time period

1-2 years after tree death or green failure

Primary fuel type(s)

Surface

Fire effects

Very readily ignited, can serve as fuel ladder to carry surface fire to canopy

Fuel stage

Failed2. Large diameter stems, fine branches, few to no leaves

failed defoliated

failed 2

Time period

2-4 years after tree death or green failure

Primary fuel type(s)

Surface

Fire effects

Readily ignited, can serve as ground to canopy fuel ladder

Fuel stage

Failed3. Primarily large diameter branches, fine fuels mostly rotted and in or near duff layer

failed defoliated icon

Failed 3

Time period

3-8+ years after tree death or green failure

Primary fuel type(s)

Surface

Fire effects

Increases total ground fuels, but debris piles are generally low, typically no more than 1 m tall

Fuel stage

Failed4. Decayed large diameter stems, all small branches decayed

Failed totally decayed

Failed 4

Time period

6-10+ years after tree death or green failure

Primary fuel type(s)

Surface

Fire effects

Minimal contribution to ground fuels

 

 

Table 3-7—Time sequences of degradation of aerial and ground fuels in three coast live oaks killed by SOD

Icon

Photo and description

dead standing icon

dead w leavesTree crown in year of tree death. Fuel stage Dead1.

dead standing partial defol icon

dead and mostly defolOne year later. Fuel stage is intermediate between Dead1 and Dead2. Several large branches have failed.

dead standing failed br icon

standing dead w failed branchesTwo years later. By two years after death, this tree has progressed to fuel stage Dead3. (Marin Co.)

   

Failed defoliated icon

first year failed Tree died and was defoliated before the trunk failed two years later. Fuel stage Failed2.

Failed w failed branches icon

second year failed One year later. Fuel stage intermediate between Failed2 and Failed3

Failed w many failed br icon

Three years after failThree years later. Fuel stage Failed3. (Marin Co.)

   
Failed w leaves icon

one month after failLarge tree about 1-2 months after live failure. Fuel stage Failed1.

Failed w many failed br icon

three years after failThree years after failure. Fuel stage Failed3. Note sprout growth from stump.

failed snag eight years after failEight years after failure. Fuel stage still Failed3. (Marin Co.)